Review

work/review-page·1 round 1 reply to read·1 open

the Files changed half, all changes: the tree with the file being read marked, the comments' stepper, the stale-base line where the refresh could not land, the diff, a thread on its line, the composer, a between-hunk control, and the half's own finish

←→ step commits · shift←→ step comments · a all changes · j pick a commit · click any line to comment

the picker, opened: all changes, then the commits oldest first, each with its short sha and how long ago it was committed

main is 3 commits behind upstream, so this diff may include work already on main. (fatal: could not resolve host: github.com)

Files 17

▸ client/8

▸ src/5

▸ review/3

Review.svelte +400 1

view.ts +125

view.test.ts +165

▸ session/2

wire.ts +163 1

wire.test.ts +92 -1

client/src/session/wire.ts 1 thread

open wire.ts · line 199 not drawn: the file content is not in hand

@@ -189,6 +189,7 @@
190	key: string \| null;	190	key: string \| null;
		191	/** Whether this seat's
		192	* rides the snapshot. */
		open wire.ts · line 199 you edit This read is the page's whole input; say so on the type. respond resolve delete Respond to this thread... send cancel
		194	export type ReadWire<T> =
		195	\| { outcome: 'read'; value: T }
		client/src/session/wire.ts · line 199 Comment on this line... comment cancel client/src/session/wire.ts · line 199 0:07 2 ready 412 fr 251.5 KB 32 KB/s ✕ comment cancel
	@@ -240,5 +242,5 @@
242	const held = read.wire;	242	const held = read.wire;
		243	const reviews = held.reviews;

finish review (1)

the Conversation half: what cannot be placed, the rounds, and the finish

Outdated 1

outdated client/src/session/wire.ts · line 199

captured when the comment was written

export type ReadWire<T> =
  | { outcome: 'read'; value: T }
  | { outcome: 'failed'; value: string }

youR1

The unknown-outcome arm needs to survive the parse - a read that answered something is not a failed one.

Rounds newest first

R1 3m 1 open 1 addressed 1 outdated

First pass: the signature and the doc comment.

addressed client/src/review/Review.svelte · line 74

youR1

The header says Review but the seat it belongs to is only in the back link. Name the seat here too?

implementer2m

Named it - the header now carries the branch beside the title. The E0038 was the object-safety change; #[async_trait] is back on the trait.

respond resolve delete

resolved That resolves it - the count comes from the round itself. client/src/review/view.ts · line 76

open client/src/review/view.ts · line 54

youR1

This counts waits and opens; should it also say how many rounds are unsettled?

respond resolve

Finish

Comments written on the diff file into the next round when you finish the review.

summary (optional)

finish review (1)

Before the diff

Reading the base for the diff...

The page's own read builds the record and checks the base before it draws the diff; only a seat with no session waits on that check, since nothing else would deliver it. While it works this line is the whole page; a refusal takes its place in the server's own words.